Response from the "help desk" re deceptive Rhee petition

Goldenberg’s earlier post on this matter is here. If you’d like to weigh in on whether should continue diverting nearly ALL signers of progressive education petitions  to Michelle Rhee’s, promoting the elimination of  teacher seniority protections, deceptively entitled “Save Great Teachers,” send a message to and cc.  Also check out on more on the Rhee record.

from Michael Paul Goldenberg, PAA member to You’ve likely received other messages informing you of the exchange I recently had with the head of the Michigan Senate Education Committee that was spurred by my mistaking an anti-seniority petition from Michelle Rhee and her associates for one that was actually about SUPPORTING Michigan teachers and public education.

That petition was unceremoniously thrust in front of me in rapid fire order after I’d signed a different petition via your site. Normally, I’m rather circumspect about putting my name to something, but somehow the fact that it SEEMED on the surface to be in favor of something I do support (quality education) and that it came via your organization misled me.

In future, I will be very hesitant to consider signing other petitions that come my way from lest I be similarly sucked into supporting Rhee or anyone like her. I consider her to be one of the most dangerous, dishonest people with a loud voice in the fight to privatize US public education. Her group, “Students First,” is hypocritically named and has nothing to do with what it would like to mislead the public into think it is focused upon. Ms. Rhee is about Ms. Rhee and Ms. Rhee’s career and bank account.

Rhee’s absolute failure to properly investigate the cheating scandal she helped cause speaks volumes about her lack of principles and willingness to do anything to keep herself in the public eye as another fraudulent “miracle worker.” The only miracle about Ms. Rhee is that she’s still getting away with it. If your group allows her to mislead your readers, I’m afraid you’re going to lose quite a lot of support, at least if I have anything to say about it.

Sincerely, Michael Paul Goldenberg


from Arturo Holloway, The Help Desk:  Hi Michael,   Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts on this.  We fully realize the current education debate is a complicated one,  with many people that feel strongly about Students First — both in support and opposition.  As an open platform that enables social change organizations to promote  causes to people around the world, doesn’t take a position on the means or tactics those organizations use to achieve their goals. You can read our full client policy here:

Thanks again for getting in touch about your concerns. I’ve made sure your communication was shared with the appropriate people on our team.

Best Regards, Arturo


From: Michael Paul Goldenberg to Arturo Holloway of Mr. Holloway:  Just the sort of response I expected: “We have no principles and we take no responsibility for the tactics of those who use our services.  Caveat emptor and all that, you know!”  I really should thank you, though. The unprincipled petition you put in my face led me to write a long, pointed reply to Michigan state senator Pavlov. It’s getting very wide distribution and seems to have struck a note for a lot of people. So even weasels can on occasion do good, in spite of themselves.

Keep telling yourselves that you have no dog in this fight and no responsibility.

Posted on by admin Posted in Uncategorized

11 Responses to Response from the "help desk" re deceptive Rhee petition

  1. Pingback: More on Rhee's astroturf efforts

  2. Pingback: Why are & Care2 hyping #edreform for the 1%? :: Sabrina Stevens Shupe