PAA Position Paper
Parents Stand Up against Test Stress
Updated January 2016
Across our nation, children of all ages are showing a jump in test anxiety. As high-stakes standardized tests have multiplied, growing percentages of students have begun to report test-related stress. More are seeking test-stress counseling. Media reports of psychological and physiological symptoms tied to testing have increased.
Some students are able to manage the pressures of high-stakes testing. Others are overwhelmed. Parents, teachers, administrators, and mental health professionals report symptoms that include nausea, dizziness, crying, vomiting, panic attacks, asthma attacks, tantrums, headaches, sleeplessness, refusal to go to school, “freaking out,” meltdowns, depression, suicide threats and suicide attempts.
Recent research has demonstrated that prolonged stress can profoundly undermine learning, mental health and brain development in young people. The stress that high-stakes testing creates is thus sabotaging learning for many students.
Test stress does particular harm to our most vulnerable children. Students with special needs, low-income students, children of color and those whose first language is not English are most likely to do poorly on standardized tests, and most likely to attend struggling schools where the focus on test results is particularly intense. One study has found that as many as 41 percent of African American elementary school children have experienced high test anxiety.
Much of the literature on test anxiety focuses on how to help children cope with the stress. In contrast, PAA believes the cause of the stress must be addressed. No child should be exposed to prolonged, intense stress, which can inhibit brain function and take a toll on mental health.
End high-stakes standardized testing: A switch from high-stakes testing to a systematic review of actual student work would
lessen excessive test stress that undermines learning,
provide superior evidence of academic progress, and
enrich classroom experiences.
Rely instead on regular teacher-generated reports of student progress which
are prepared by experienced, qualified adults who personally observe each student, and
are accessible to parents, unlike secretive standardized test scores.
De-emphasize The Tests: JUST SAY NO to test pep rallies, test prep worksheets that replace meaningful class- and homework, constant messages about the consequences of test “failure,” prizes for test-takers, etc.
Recognize opt-out rights: Parents are opting their children out of testing in record numbers, in part to protect them from the stress caused by misuse and overuse of standardized tests. Federal and state law must support this decision by parents.
Advocate for local and state assessment policies that align with professional standards for assessment.
Dr. Nancy Carlsson-Paige, Professor Emerita, Lesley University
Defending the Early Years
Dr. Peter Gray, research professor in the department of Psychology, Boston College
Alfie Kohn, educator and author, The Case Against Standardized Testing
Jonathan Kozol, educator and author of Savage Inequalities and Shame of a Nation
Dr. Roxana Marachi, Associate Professor of Education, San José State University
Geralyn Bywater McLaughlin, Director, Defending the Early Years
Dr. Mark Naison, Professor of History, Fordham University
Dr. Monty Neill, executive director, FairTest
Dr. Isabel Nunez, Associate Professor in the Center for Policy and Social Justice, Concordia University Chicago
Susan Ochshorn, Founder, ECE PolicyWorks, author of Squandering America’s Future: Why ECE Policy Matters for Equality, Our Economy, and Our Children
Dr. Julian Vasquez-Heilig, Professor of Educational Leadership and Policy Studies and the Director of the Doctorate in Educational Leadership at California State Sacramento